October 31, 2012 ~ 2 Comments

Beyond Grantmaking: Program-Related Investing and Modern Philanthropy

New Treasury regulations on program-related investments (PRIs) are generating renewed interest among private foundations seeking a more market-based way to further their charitable purposes.  PRIs are an exception to the excise tax on jeopardizing investments, allowing private foundations to serve as venture capitalists, business incubators, and “social entrepreneurs” in furtherance of their exempt purposes.

The new regulations add 9 new examples illustrating the incredible flexibility of PRIs, but do not modify the existing rules.  The examples show that private foundations can fund research and development, provide seed capital to domestic and foreign for-profit companies, use any manner of financial structure (debt, equity, or a combination of both), and count it all as “qualifying distributions” for the year. 

What makes PRIs attractive?

 1.  Unlike grants, PRI money is supposed to come back, often with some return on investment.  Loans may be repaid, stock sold.

 2.  PRIs generally count as a qualifying distribution for purposes of a private foundation’s annual distribution requirement – generally 5% of net assets. 

 3.  When PRI funds do come back, the amount is added to that year’s distribution requirement.  That provides another shot at making another PRI (or a grant) with the funds.

 4.  PRIs effectively provide a hidden 5% return.  The asset purchased with the PRI, an equity stake in a company or a note receivable, for example, is not included in calculating net assets for purposes of the 5% minimum annual distribution.  So, a 2% loan can be seen to provide a 7% return.

 5.  PRIs can be used as a “smoothing” tool for a private foundation’s grant-making program.  When markets are up, annual distribution requirements increase.  Grantees can quickly become reliant on the increased revenue, only to see a decrease when markets come back down. Private foundations can make PRIs with “extra” qualifying distribution dollars when the markets are up, and hope to see the funds return when markets are down.  That way, private foundations can keep their grantees on a diet of steadily increasing funds, rather than one with wild fluctuations.

 6.  While the production of income or the appreciation of property cannot be a significant purpose of a PRI, the potential for a high rate of return is not a PRI killer. 

 7.  Adding PRIs to a private foundation’s toolkit may be relatively simple.  I tend to utilize a foundation’s existing grantmaking processes and documents to facilitate PRIs.

Among many other good things they can do, PRIs seem ideally suited to pick up where government sponsored R&D seems to have left off.  For example, a company called Solaren, using existing technology, seeks to produce zero emission, 24/7, cost-competitive electricity from solar power collected in space.  The solar power is converted to electricity, which is converted to radio waves, which are transmitted to a fixed location on earth and then converted back to electricity.  They are looking for funds to optimize, test and validate the system with a kilowatt scale prototype – a step which so far appears to be a prerequisite to tapping commercial equity markets. 

An environmentally-focused private foundation could make a PRI to bridge the gap, include the PRI as a “qualifying distribution,” exclude its Solaren stock from its 5% distribution requirement, potentially make a blockbuster return and, not least, improve global air quality and stem global warming.

Thank you for reading,

Ofer Lion

Ofer Lion, counsel with Hunton & Williams LLP, focuses his practice on tax-exempt organizations and nonprofits, including hospitals and health care organizations, universities and schools, research institutions, public charities, private foundations and private operating foundations. http://www.hunton.com/ofer_lion/.

2 Responses to “Beyond Grantmaking: Program-Related Investing and Modern Philanthropy”

  1. tesla power innovator program 11 January 2015 at 4:40 pm Permalink

    Energy Innovator Application
    Energy Innovator Software is a step-by-step framework that has been composed by way of Dr.
    Richard Goran to hep people make their very ownn power that mayy
    be simple and straightforward to make use of. In fact, this mission is easy to the purpose that
    evwn a child can understand the guidelines and benefit fromm it frokm the very first second.By using Power Innnovator Application you’ll soon in finding that you’ll be able to undoubtedly make your own particular energy.

    You’ll bee able to without much of a stretch spare several
    greenbacks to your power expenses as a way tto genuinely come as a aid to many.

    You’ll likewise bewar the system so yoou can uutilize it whilst yoou require it without
    any inconvenience.
    Through what method ccan Energy Innovator Program let you?Succh a lot importantly, by utilizing this system you are going to manage to save lot of cash
    tha you total pay as energy expenses. A lot of have officially affirmed that they’ve possessed the capability to cut back electrical energy bills via 80% from first month by myself.

    Next, it can be the most efficient spouse at the
    off chance that you just reside in misfortune inclined territories.
    Casse in point, when tropical storms happen, or titanic storms occur, bringing
    approximately far achieving hurt to the power grid, you’ll bbe able to make the most
    of Energy Innovator for uncertain length. It’s consummately advantageous as you’ll be able to watch your so much beloved initiatives on TV or
    retailer your nourishment inn refrigerator for a considerable size
    of time.With this framework, it’s going to be a loot much less demanding for you to positioned one thing apart for more imperative issues, for example, your children’ coaching, or puut
    one thing apart for crises.
    OptionsEven iff you gained’t find any rewards incorporated on this item, on the other
    hand there are a largbe number of stunning peculiarities of
    this prkgram that makes it most attractive one to bee had.

    The most productive oone is that you’ll utilize it very nearly for any apparatus in you home, regardless of what its
    This framework can paintings in point of fact whilst situation is unfavourable.

    That means nnow you received’t wish to rigidity at everywhere lengthy energy slices because of storms or
    community disappointment. Wiith Energy Innobator you can be rest guaranteed that your existence wiill keep as prior to with none disturbance.

    It’s a bit software aand will also fit in your pocket. So that you gained’t want
    so much house. Although it’s a bit of system, it
    may possibly at present scale back electricity expenses by 80%.

    Benefits• This challenge can work for each particular person. It implies without reference
    to how younger or oold you’re, or regardless of the reality that you
    are a non-technical particular person; you’ll unquestionably follow tthe information give
    to you in the bubdle andd manufacture the framework.

    • You’ll get monetary savings on vitality bills.

    my homepage tesla power innovator program

Leave a Comment